Cindy Gladue Case: Not Guilty Verdict Ignites Outrage, Protests

 WARNING: This story contains graphic details. The following information about violence may be triggering to survivors.

The circumstances of Cindy Gladue’s last hours were horrific. The mother of two bled to death in a motel bathtub, suffering from an 11-centimetre vaginal wound.

And the trial of the man accused of killing her was no less appalling, say aboriginal activists.

Cindy Gladue.

Cindy Gladue.

Earlier this month, an Edmonton jury found Ontario trucker Bradley Barton not guilty of first-degree murder in the 2011 death of Gladue, a First Nations woman.

Outrage over the verdict has spurred a letter-writing campaign, asking the Crown to initiate an appeal. An online petition is also collecting support for another trial. Protests across Canada are planned this week.

Barton, 46, testified at his month-long trial that Gladue’s injury was accidentally caused by rough sex when he thrust his fingers into her, reported the Edmonton Journal.

The Crown argued that Gladue — whose blood alcohol level was four times the legal limit — could not have have agreed to sex, and that Barton intentionally stabbed the sex trade worker, reported The Globe and Mail.

Alberta’s chief medical examiner brought Gladue’s preserved vagina into court as evidence, arguing that the jury needed to understand the nature of the wound. It was the first time part of a body has been presented as evidence at a Canadian trial, reported CBC News.

“Whatever you decide, this is not an accident,” Crown prosecutor Carrie-Ann Downey told the jury.

The jury of nine men and two women acquitted Barton of both first-degree murder and manslaughter on March 18.

“This is another example of the way aboriginal women in Canada are marginalized, erased, and denied justice,” said Edmonton activist Fawn Lamouche in a news release.

After the decision, the Journal reported that Barton’s laptop showed he visited pornography websites featuring “extreme penetration and torture.” The evidence was not introduced at the trial after the judge ruled it wasn’t obtained lawfully by investigators.

Protests for justice

Rallies are being organized in at least 14 Canadian cities on Thursday to protest the verdict. The events have the support of Amnesty International, Idle no More, and the Institute for the Advancement of Aboriginal Women, said Lamouche.

Organizers point out that a 2014 RCMP report found 1,017 aboriginal women and girls were killed between 1980 and 2012, a homicide rate about 4.5 times higher than that of all other women in Canada.

The Edmonton acquittal just shows how violence against indigenous women is normalized, wrote scholar Sarah Hunt and activist Naomi Sayers in a column for The Globe and Mail. They also argued that bringing Gladue’s pelvis into the courtroom was another dehumanization of aboriginal people.

One of Gladue’s daughters wrote on Facebook this week: “I cannot believe it’s been almost 4 years, I miss you so much and I wish you could be here to meet my beautiful baby.”

Gladue’s family are owed justice, say supporters.

Where is the collective outrage?,” wrote Julie Kaye, an assistant professor of sociology at the King’s University in Edmonton. “The Gladue family deserves an appeal. Indigenous women and women in sex industries deserve an appeal. Sex workers do not consent to blunt trauma and 11-centimetre tears and death. Cindy Gladue did not consent to violence.”

Posted on March 31, 2015, in Indigenous Women and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 4 Comments.

  1. Sick bastards!
    Not only the thing that did this to her, but the things Lawyer and the firm their outta, the Judge and Jury as well as anyone else who believes it was an accident. Left in a tub?? No hospital? No ambulance? 11 centimetres?? Nasty porn evidence? Unlawfully obtained???? That’s putting out a message… If your sick in the head, know the law before you offend and have a good lawyer. Protect your wife and kids people, the law let another sick @$&# out into your community!
    Way to go Canada

    • My suggestion the court should have even out the jurors 5 men and 5 women balance the decision’s point of view. also the violent death this lady endured is devastating to all the women regardless who they are. the evidence unreal.

  2. Yes, this is extremely disturbing, it is always extreme and disturbing yet the apathy is like the fog, it drifts in and sits doing nothing more than preventing the sunshine from reaching us.

    ‘The evidence was not introduced at the trial after the judge ruled it wasn’t obtained lawfully by investigators.’ Now one would think if it was ones profession to lawfully gather evidence one would actually be capable of doing that. Just saying I expect and expert to be spot on ninety or more percent of the time, if purpose is success but being if you read and keep track of the verdicts in criminal cases you will find a fifty or more percent failure and stay’s being handed out. So very disturbed people, like the one who did that go back to doing what they do and THAT is NOT something to be apathetic about.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: