Peaceful Protests Profit from History of Militant Resistance

by Zig Zag, Warrior Publications, January 12, 2013

Warrior at Oka, 1990, standing on top of abandoned & over turned police car.

Warrior at Oka, 1990, standing on top of abandoned & over turned police car.

“Unbelievable how chicken the police are to remove these people from blocking the railway. If it was anybody but natives they would have been arrested a week ago.”

Letter posted by Gerry, Jan 2, 2013, “First Nation blockade in Sarnia coming down,” Canadian Press, Jan 2, 2013

Any time there is a significant Native blockade or occupation, there are demands for its immediate removal by angry citizens. During Oka, 1990, and Six Nations 2006, for example, mobs of non-Natives rallied and sometimes rioted demanding that the military intervene to end the disputes.

Likewise, judges have scolded police forces who did not immediately enforce injunctions that they issued against blockades or occupations. A recent example was seen in Sarnia, Ontario, where Natives blockaded a CN rail for several days as part of the Idle No More mobilization. In late December, Ontario Superior Court Judge David Brown issued an injunction against the blockade. Sarnia police never did enforce it, and instead the blockade was voluntarily dismantled by protesters.

Then on January 5, 2013, the same judge issued an emergency injunction against a train blockade carried out by Tyendinaga Mohawks. Citing tactical reasons, the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) did not intervene, and the blockade was voluntarily taken down after a few hours by the Mohawks.

Blockade of CN rail line near Sarnia, Ontario.

Blockade of CN rail line near Sarnia, Ontario.

Last spring, B.C. Supreme Court Judge Mark McEwan criticized the RCMP for failing to enforce an injunction against the blockade of the Gitxsan Treaty Society by grassroots Gitxsan (after Elmer Derrick, head of the GTS, signed a multi-million dollar deal with Enbridge). The blockade, which began in early December, 2011, lasted for several months and only ended when a deal was reached whereby an audit would be undertaken of the GTS finances.

Many Idle No More rallies have seen little police presence, aside from redirecting traffic, even when several hundred people are marching. Blockades of highways and city intersections have lasted at times for 3-4 hours. Hundreds have “flash mobbed” into shopping malls, causing minor disruptions to business-as-usual, with little police response.

Some INM participants see this as proof that “peaceful” protests are effective, that police don’t know how to respond to them, etc. But it would be good to remember that the Occupy protests of 2011, even though being almost entirely nonviolent, were squashed with court injunctions and the frequent deployment of riot police. Even the first Occupy rally in Vancouver, on October 15, 2011, saw scores of riot cops in the streets.

What all of these people—the reactionary citizen, judges, and the naive INM participant—don’t realize is that the reason the state and its police forces “fail to act” is that they fear the greater potential disruption that Indigenous peoples are capable of. The state does not want to radicalize a passive reformist movement through overt repression, and will tolerate acts of civil disobedience (including temporary blockades of infrastructure).

Six Nations 2006: grassroots Indigenous resistance in action.

Six Nations 2006: grassroots Indigenous resistance in action.

The greater potential for disruption is not merely a phantom menace, but has been seen before. During the Oka Crisis of 1990, for example, it was the widespread and militant solidarity actions carried out by grassroots people that limited the state’s military options in ending the standoff. These solidarity actions included protests, blockades of highways, railways and bridges, occupations of government offices, as well as sabotage of railway bridges and power lines.

The state knows that Indigenous populations are, in rural areas especially, strategically located to cause massive economic disruption. This includes blocking or cutting highways, railways and power lines that cross through Indigenous territories and reserve lands.

In addition, the Indigenous grassroots has demonstrated a capability for militant as well as armed resistance, as the examples of Oka 1990, Gustafsen Lake and Ipperwash 1995, Burnt Church 1999-2000, Kahnesatake (Oka) 2004, Six Nations 2006, etc., clearly show.Real Grassroots meme 2

So while some INM’ers believe they are leading a “peaceful” Indigenous Rights Revolution, they are actually benefiting from the militant grassroots resistance that preceded them, gained through blood, sweat, and tears, assaults, arrests, and in some cases death. Perhaps if they knew their history better, they would understand this.

Posted on January 13, 2013, in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 11 Comments.

  1. Hiy Hiy

  2. It’s not believable that police just decided on their own not to enforce the injunction. They were ordered to react as they did. Why? To use the blockades in some political way? Seems like the next step in the response will be to slander and criminalize people and try to isolate them. Making divisions and exploiting existing tensions in communities are standard tactics.

    Thank you for the great analysis.

  3. Actually, one of the police officer in Sarnia decided to stay and support the protesters for a while.
    But the main reason the police did not immediatly enforce the injunctions in these cases is because, as Zig Zag wrote, they were afraid of turning peaceful protesters into proactive warriors were they to enforce the court’s order directly, in other words, violently.

    Also, there is a special case in law when it comes to protests staged by warriors; given the numerous examples given by Zig Zag of militant grassroots resistance, the police is now allowed by law not to enforce an injunction immediatly when the protest is about land claims.

  4. I agree with this take on historical analysis.

  5. No question, you are right.
    Whatever is gained by peaceful protest relies on an unspoken knowledge that escalation to blockades, etc is possible.

    All of the history of Indigenous resistance is coalescing into the strength of the Idle No More movement. All of that history is necessary for this moment to occur.
    There is no competition for the one ‘right’ strategy: All play a role.

  6. I absolutely love this article, however I request you edit or remove the last line, which is somewhat condescending, and likely to turn off people who are already skeptical. Your arguments are well made, don’t ruin it with a snarky ending line.

    Below is a great free Video URL: Kanehsatake 270 Years of Resistance

  7. wow….. u need to understand. we know. i know. more than i should. more than you could, the real accounts of what happened. to say i dont understand my history is to say you dont understand the present. i am a son of the american indain movement. my mmother and father met on the longest walk motherfukkker. wheree did your parents meet, the bar? go fukkk yourself. edit the last paragraph now. you fail to understand the significance of the spiritual fire that was lit. every day a new soul is enlightened on the long standing 520 year resistance. enlightened. their spirit is touched with knowledge of their rights and the wrongs done to them. are you native? if you are warrior, go sweat. thoughts like that will destroy you. you must wanna be geronimo talking down all the other warriors supporting idle no more.

  1. Pingback: Peaceful Protests Profit from History of Militant Resistance | Warrior Publications | robot son link blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: